Cardano Rejects Request for 22 Million ADA to Purchase Copper

Delegated representatives of Cardano (DReps) rejected Toto Finance's proposal to allocate 22 million ADA from the blockchain treasury to create a physical copper reserve. The application review period ended on November 15, and the necessary conditions for its approval were not met.
According to data from the Cardanoscan blockchain explorer, the proposal received support from only 0.51% of the DRep votes considered, with a required threshold of 67%. Five representatives voted for the funding, while 126 voted against it.
In terms of delegated funds, the proposal was supported by participants with 20.02 million ADA, while explicit votes against amounted to 2.86 billion ADA. Thus, the weight of the votes against exceeded the support by more than 140 times.
None of the seven members of the Cardano Constitutional Committee approved the application. Three deemed it non-compliant with the network's Constitution, while the remaining four did not vote.
What Toto Finance Planned to Spend the Funds On
The Cardano Strategic Copper Reserve proposal was submitted on October 15. Toto Finance planned to allocate 14.72 million ADA, or about 66.93% of the budget, for the purchase of COMEX Grade 1 copper cathodes, with subsequent storage in a specialized warehouse in the USA.
The remaining funds were intended for the development of technological infrastructure, operational expenses, auditing, and independent control.
The company also planned to issue CuTT tokens, each representing one pound of physical copper. The initial issuance was planned on the Ethereum network, with subsequent transfer of the tokenized representation to Cardano via an inter-network bridge.
This architecture raised questions among some DReps, as the funding was requested from the Cardano treasury, while the base token issuance was planned on another blockchain network.
Why Cardano Representatives Opposed
The main objections concerned the project's cost, the protection of treasury funds, and the lack of guarantees for the return of the initial funding.
Under the proposal's terms, the copper was to be stored for 18–24 months and then sold. Toto Finance planned to return the net proceeds and unused funds to the treasury within 36 months, but did not guarantee reimbursement of the initial 22 million ADA.
With full utilization of the allocated budget and an unchanged ADA rate, the price of copper would need to rise by approximately 49% for the revenue from the metal's sale to cover the initial funding amount.
Additional concerns arose from the fact that certain mechanisms of independent control and asset protection had not yet been implemented. In particular, the proposal provided for the initial receipt of treasury funds into an account controlled by Toto Finance before the completion of subsequent protective procedures.
What the Rejection Means for the Cardano Treasury
Since the proposal did not receive the necessary support, 22 million ADA from the treasury were not allocated.
According to DRepTalk, approximately 457.4 million ADA of the current withdrawal limit of 500 million ADA has already been used. The available amount for new withdrawals is approximately 42.6 million ADA.
Toto Finance's request accounted for approximately 51.6% of this remaining balance. Its rejection preserved the available limit for considering other initiatives.
However, 42.6 million ADA is not the total balance of the Cardano treasury, but the remaining funding capability within the established limit.
At an ADA rate of about $0.15 on November 16, the requested 22 million tokens corresponded to approximately $3.3 million. At the time of the project's initial discussion, its estimated cost was approaching $5 million.
This material is prepared solely for informational purposes and does not constitute financial advice or a recommendation.



